One afternoon Claire knocked, carrying a small tin of oatmeal cookies. June used to make them with too much cinnamon. Claire had burned the edges the same way.

“I knew you’d say no,” she told me. “So I let Peter make you think there was nothing to say no to.”

I poured coffee. She didn’t ask for forgiveness or money. She asked whether she could come by again, and I said we’d start with a phone call next Sunday.

When she left, I put June’s old photograph back beside my cup. The daffodils outside had begun to bloom.

Sunday came. My phone rang at four.

This time, when Claire said, “Hi, Dad,” I knew she was speaking to me—not waiting for the moment I stopped listening.